Human Resource & Labor News
www.agc.orgNovember 8, 2011 / Issue No. 6-11
AGC Home Page
Email our Editor
Search Back Issues
Forward to a Friend
Printer Friendly
On the Inside
Regulations & Enforcement
Government Agencies Partner to Enforce Independent Contractor Misclassifications; IRS Offers Risky Settlement Program
FAR Council Issues Final Rules on Labor Laws Notice and on Labor Relations Costs
AGC Objects to Labor Department’s “Persuader Rule”
NLRB Delays Effective Date of Posting Requirement While AGC-Supported Coalition Joins Lawsuit to Block Rule
Labor Department Provides Interim Guidance on Electronic Fee Disclosures
EEOC Opinion Letter Provides Guidance on Use of Arrest and Conviction Records When Hiring
IRS Provides Guidance on Tax Treatment of Employer-Provided Cell Phones
Union Contracting
Union Contractors Meet with Basic Trade Leaders and Hold Strategic Planning Session
FASB Issues New Multiemployer Plan Disclosure Standard; Update Represents Victory for AGC
Professional Development
AGC to Provide Two-Part, Advanced Davis-Bacon Webinar
Co-located HR Professionals and TED Conferences Continue to Grow; 2012 Conference Dates & Location Announced
EEOC Opinion Letter Provides Guidance on Use of Arrest and Conviction Records When Hiring

In response to an employer’s request, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) recently issued a non-binding opinion letter that provides insight into the Commission’s current enforcement position regarding protections for job applicants with arrest or conviction records under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.  The letter suggests that the Commission will continue to treat arrests and convictions differently and will closely review the employer’s policy with regard to how long convictions are disqualifying and whether the underlying criminal conduct is related to the job duties for the position in question.

Regarding conviction records, the EEOC states that criminal conduct should be “recent enough” and “sufficiently job-related to be predictive of performance in the position sought, given its duties and responsibilities.”  As a result, the EEOC recommended that the employer narrow its criminal history inquiry to focus on “convictions that are related to the specific positions in questions, and that have taken place in the past seven years, consistent with the proposed provisions of the federal government’s general employment application form.”  Because the criminal justice system requires the highest degree of proof for a conviction (i.e., beyond a reasonable doubt), a conviction record can serve as a sufficient indication that the person, in fact, committed the offense.  Regarding arrest records, the EEOC explains that they are unreliable indicators of guilt because: (1) individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty; (2) charges may be incomplete or eventually dropped; and (3) the possibility of errors in arrest records including mistaken identities, clerical errors, confusion regarding names, etc. 

While the letter clarifies that a pre-employment inquiry concerning an applicant’s criminal history does not itself violate Title VII, it does suggest that the use of criminal records as part of the screening process may be a violation if the employer intentionally and selectively enforces its screening policy against members of protected classes.  The letter further explains that if it is determined that the policy has a disparate impact on protected class members, the employer’s policy regarding the use of arrest and conviction records must be “job related and consistent with business necessity.”

Even though the EEOC states that the letter “does not constitute an official opinion of the Commission,” it does suggest that this is a high priority area for the EEOC.  As a result, employers should review their screening policies and practices as they relate to arrest and conviction records to identify any possible risks of disparate treatment or disparate impact.  

For additional information on pre-employment inquiries regarding arrests and conviction records, visit the EEOC website.  For pre-employment resources and tools, including checklists and sample forms, visit AGC’s Labor & HR Topical Resources webpage.  The primary category is “Hiring & Firing” and the secondary category is “Hiring.”

Return to Top

2300 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 400 • Arlington, VA 22201 • 703.548.3118 (phone) • 703.548.3119 (fax) •
AGC Home | About AGC | Advocacy | Industry Topics | Construction Markets | Programs & Events | Career Development | News & Media

To ensure delivery of AGC’s Human Resource & Labor News, please add '' to your email address book or Safe Sender List. If you are still having problems receiving our communications, visit our white-listing page for more details.

© Copyright The Associated General Contractors (AGC) of America. All Rights Reserved.

The Associated General Contractors of America | Quality People. Quality Projects.