Human Resource & Labor News
www.agc.orgFebruary 6, 2014 / Issue No. 01-14
AGC Home Page
Email our Editor
Search Back Issues
Forward to a Friend
Printer Friendly
On the Inside
Labor Law
NLRB Re-Proposes "Quickie Election" Rule
NLRB Abandons Notice-Posting Rule
Circuit Court Validates Class Action Waivers in Employment Arbitration Agreements
Wage-Hour Law
Supreme Court Clarifies Meaning of “Changing Clothes” Under The Fair Labor Standards Act
Federal Contracting
OFCCP’s Disability and Veterans Rules Effective March 24, Mandatory Self-ID Form Released
Recording of AGC’s Latest Davis-Bacon Webinar Series Now Available
Labor Department Provides Clarification on Application of Davis-Bacon to Survey Crews
Union Contracting
Updated Inventory of Construction-Industry Multiemployer Pension Plans Released as Advocacy Efforts for Reform Continue
Collective Bargaining in 2013 Yields Average 1st-Year Increase of 2.2 Percent
Construction Union Membership and Members’ Earnings Both Rise in 2013, While Nonunion Workers’ Earnings Decline
HR Practice
Save the Date: 2014 Construction HR and Training Professionals Conference Set for Oct. 15-17 in Phoenix, Arizona
Health FSA Rules Modified to Allow Carryover
Counting the Cost of Payroll Cards: Are They Worth It for Employers?
Construction Firms Plan to Hire in 2014, Worry About Worker Shortages
Circuit Court Validates Class Action Waivers in Employment Arbitration Agreements

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit (LA, MS, TX) has overturned a National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB” or “Board”) decision prohibiting employers from requiring employees to sign arbitration agreements containing waivers of the right to pursue class action and collective action claims in court or arbitration.  As reported earlier, the NLRB ruled that such a requirement interferes with employees’ rights under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act to engage in protected concerted activity.  The court disagreed, finding that the NLRB failed to give proper weight to the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”). 

The court acknowledged that some cases lend support to the NLRB’s finding that collective and class claims are protected by Section 7.  However, the FAA “has equal importance,” said the court, and “caselaw under the FAA points us in a different direction than the course taken by the Board.”  The FAA  generally requires enforcement of arbitration agreements according to their terms.  The two exceptions to the rule were at issue in this case:  (1) an arbitration agreement may be invalidated on any ground that would invalidate a contract under the FAA's "saving clause;” and (2) application of the FAA may be precluded by another statute's contrary congressional command.  After conducting a lengthy analysis, the court concluded that neither of the exceptions applied.

The court did uphold part of the Board’s decision, though.  It found substantial evidence to support the conclusion that the particular arbitration agreement involved in the case violated the NRLA because employees could reasonably understand it to preclude them from filing unfair labor practice charges with the NRLB.  The court, therefore, enforced the Board’s order requiring the employer to revise the agreement to clarify that employees remain free to pursue such charges with the NLRB.

Many observers think that this case, or another case like it, will go to the Supreme Court.  AGC will report on any significant developments.  Meanwhile, members are encouraged to seek legal counsel to review any mandatory arbitration agreements in place.

D.R. Horton, Inc. v. NLRB, Case No. 12-60031 (5th Cir., 12/3/13).
Return to Top


2300 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 400 • Arlington, VA 22201 • 703.548.3118 (phone) • 703.548.3119 (fax) •
AGC Home | About AGC | Advocacy | Industry Topics | Construction Markets | Programs & Events | Career Development | News & Media

To ensure delivery of AGC’s Human Resource & Labor News, please add '' to your email address book or Safe Sender List. If you are still having problems receiving our communications, visit our white-listing page for more details.

© Copyright The Associated General Contractors (AGC) of America. All Rights Reserved.

The Associated General Contractors of America | Quality People. Quality Projects.