Two by Jeglic and Calkins |
Submitted by David S. Prescott, Forum Review Editor |
These two reviews focus on two professors of psychology at
John Jay College and prolific contributors to our field, Elizabeth L. Jeglic
and Cynthia Calkins. Jeglic and Calkins are each on the Editorial Board of
Sexual Abuse, also known by members as “The ATSA Journal.” The first is an
edited volume intended for a scholarly audience, while the second is for a
general audience readership (primarily parents and teachers) interested in
protecting their children.
Sexual Violence:
Evidence Based Policy and Prevention
Elizabeth L. Jeglic
and Cynthia Calkins, Editors
2016: Springer, New
York
336 pages, USD
$138.00
Policy and prevention have long been a primary interest of
ATSA members, with the organization focusing for many years in these directions
through its committee work, amicus briefs, white papers, etc. This edited
volume serves as a “who’s who” of researchers in the field of policy and
prevention. It is an excellent follow-up companion to the ATSA task force
report edited by Keith Kaufman in 2010 and published in collaboration with
NEARI Press.
Jeglic and Calkins start the volume off with an overview of
the issues addressed in subsequent chapters without summarizing their
highlights. Brandy Blasko provides an overview of considerations regarding the
typologies, recidivism, and treatment of people who have sexually abused. In
some cases, the use of historical language may be surprising (e.g., situational
versus preferential child molesters), but Blasko’s intent is to provide a
historical framework that serves as a springboard to what follows.
Policy chapters focus on the Sex Offender Registration and
Notification Act (Kristen Zgoba and Deborah Ragbir), residence restrictions
(Jill Levenson and Claudia Vicencio), civil commitment (Michelle Cubellis and
Andrew J. Harris), Internet sexual offender laws (Ashley Spada), and the use of
electronic monitoring as a supervision tool (Stephen V. Gies). Each chapter is
well-researched, often by the acknowledged leaders in the field (e.g., Jill
Levenson on residence restrictions). In some cases, there may have been a
slight over-reach in attempts to place each topic in context (there is, for
example, a discussion of castration in the chapter on electronic monitoring
that may appear out of place), but the overall result is above reproach: each
chapter extends beyond what one might find in the literature reviews of
scholarly journal articles. Indeed, some chapters are themselves extended
studies.
The second half of the volume focuses on prevention and
includes chapters on public health approaches to preventing sexual violence
(Ryan Shields and Kenneth Feder), situational approaches (Stephen Smallbone),
community-level approaches (Sarah DeGue, Tracy Hipp, and Jeffrey Herbst),
measuring the outcomes of prevention programs (Gwenda Willis and Natalie
Germann), a social norms change approach to prevention (Elizabeth Miller and
colleagues), proactive strategies to prevent child abuse and the use of child
abuse images – the Dunkelfeld Project (Klaus Beier), providing help to young
men who are sexually attracted to children (Luke Malone), the use of civil
commitment in prevention (Eric Janus), and the economics of policy and
prevention (Anthony Perillo).
As one might expect, the writing and editing make for an
easily accessible read, especially for those professionals in areas (such as
treatment provision, education, or research) that have an interest in policy
and/or prevention. It is an excellent opportunity to catch up on projects (such
as Dunkelfeld) and various authors and their perspectives (Eric Janus has
written entire books in the area of civil commitment). Likewise, it provides
newer perspectives and information (Willis and Germann’s chapter on outcomes
and their implications being a prime example).
In the end, the authors and editors are clear in their
assessments (e.g., residence restrictions “are a failure”) and recommendations.
Although more expensive than other volumes, it provides the best overview of
the issues to date in a single book.
Protecting Your Child
from Sexual Abuse: What You Need to Know to Keep Your Kids Safe
Elizabeth L. Jeglic
and Cynthia Calkins
2018: New York,
Skyhorse Publishing
158 pages, USD $8.99
Jeglic and Calkins teamed up for this volume in the wake of
the above academic project. Available in print and electronic forms, this
smaller volume provides a needed overview for parents. It is comprehensive
without becoming overbearing and will find a different audience than previous
works by authors such as Melissa Pirwani and the late Jan Hindman.
The structure and writing are user-friendly and informative.
Professionals in the field (including those in child welfare as well as those
assessing and treating abuse) can use this as a reference for parents. It moves
from an overview of myths and realities into what one can expect from sex
offender registries. It then focuses on how to start difficult conversations
and addresses the limitations of the well-known “good touch bad touch”
approach. From there, the volume turns into the direction of online dangers and
the perennial question of whom one can trust in these situations. The authors
then follow a developmental pathway, from talking to your tween, to talking to
your teen and finally the college years. The book concludes with an excellent
overview of ways that readers can help their communities to stop sexual
violence and provides questions for group discussions.
Armed with the knowledge described earlier, the authors were
almost uniquely poised to produce this book. It is an excellent resource, plain
and simple.
|