Mobile Version
July 22, 2014



In This Issue
Health Reform Subsidy Ruling May Have Profound Long-Term Impact But Causes No Immediate Market Change
E-mail the Editor
Visit the NAHU Website
Printer Friendly Version
Health Reform Subsidy Ruling May Have Profound Long-Term Impact But Causes No Immediate Market Change

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit released a 2-1 decision today in the Halbig v. Burwell case determining that the IRS and the federally facilitated exchange marketplace was not authorized to distribute premium tax credit subsidies to individual exchange consumers. The court determined that the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) unambiguously restricts the availability of subsidies to insurance purchased in state-based exchanges, and that the IRS regulation acted outside of the parameters of the PPACA by making available subsides via the federally facilitated and partnership exchanges. While this decision could eventually have huge ramifications for the health reform law, it is very important to note that the ruling does not change anything regarding the distribution of subsidies or cost-sharing assistance, the operation of the federally facilitated exchanges or enforcement of the employer mandate for the time being. In making its ruling, the D.C. Circuit Court made a very specific decision not to immediately block subsidies, acknowledging that their decision will be appealed right away.

The Obama Administration has already announced its plan to appeal today’s ruling to the full D.C. Circuit Court. Furthermore, there are two other cases still pending before other circuit courts and, in addition to those two pending cases and the D.C. Circuit Court’s ruling, a conflicting ruling was also issued today on an almost identical case by the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond. That court ruled unanimously 3-0 that the IRS has acted correctly in allowing tax subsidies to be issued via all federal and state-run exchange states. These conflicting rulings mean that this issue will almost certainly be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court later this year. If and when heard by the Supreme Court, we can expect a final decision regarding the availability of subsidies in federally facilitated marketplaces no sooner than June 2015.

So what does this mean for you as an agent and your clients right now? Since there are conflicting rulings and the decisions are being appealed, no action will be taken in the federally facilitated marketplaces to enforce the D.C. Circuit Court ruling on an immediate basis. This means... Read More

NAHU on Twitter NAHU on Facebook NAHU on LinkedIn